| |
If your every waking moment was consumed by pain and nausea, wouldnt you ask for
medication? What if the only medication legally available would leave you unconscious or
do nothing at all? If you were the one suffering, would you resort to the only treatment
that allowed you to live normally even though it was illegal? Thousands of people across
the country are forced to break the law to ease their pain. They have chosen marijuana
over anything legally available because it has various medicinal properties that cannot be
found anywhere else. Due to these many unique medicinal uses, marijuana should be
reclassified as a valid, legal form of treatment.
Marijuana has many unique uses as a form of treatment. It has been used
effectively to combat the nausea caused by chemotherapy, to reduce the internal pressure
of the eyes of glaucoma patients, and to prevent the wasting syndrome in AIDS
and cancer patients (Marijuana for the Sick A10). As an alternative to using
actual marijuana, modern science has developed a synthetic form of THC, the active
chemical in marijuana. However, this synthetic drug, called Marinol, is useless for most
everyday treatment because it has the unpleasant side effect of being a powerful sedative.
A member of Milwaukees AIDS community, said that a friend of his was taking Marinol
to increase his appetite: He spends the whole day laughing and watching movies...He
cant even drive a car because hes so out of it. (3/25/97) In addition to
that, Marinol only comes in pill form, which makes it useless for patients taking it for
nausea. Marijuana has neither of those drawbacks. Because it is usually smoked, even the
most nauseous patient can use it as well as easily regulate their intake (Medical
Marijuana 23). No prescription drug offers the benefits and potential of marijuana.
Many people have testified to marijuanas validity as a unique
form of treatment. One of these, Robert Randall, one of only eight patients supplied with
marijuana by the federal government, was diagnosed with acute glaucoma and told that he
would be blinded within five years (Brazaitis 1C). Randall discovered by accident
that smoking marijuana relieved the internal pressure of his eyes (1C). After more
than twenty years of smoking marijuana, Randall still has his vision, defying the
predictions of his doctors (2C). Richard Brookhiser, a senior editor of the conservative
National Review who has admitted to using marijuana to treat the nausea caused by
chemotherapy, claims that if that moment comes to you, you will turn to
marijuana. (Brookhiser 28) Rita Zweig further illustrates marijuanas
effectiveness: If anything that is prescribed worked as well for me, she said,
I wouldnt use marijuana. (Snider A1) These three people represent
thousands of sufferers across the country who use marijuana as a form of treatment.
Marijuana as a form of treatment has gained support from the medical
community. Such prestigious medical publications as the New England Medical Journal have
come out in support of medicinal uses for marijuana (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 1/30/97
3A). In addition to that, a Harvard study showed that nearly 44% of doctors who treat
cancer patients in the American Medical Association, a group officially opposed to
marijuana, have actually recommended marijuana to ease the pain of their patients
(Medical Marijuana 22). Even with this support, the federal government has
refused any sort of clinical testing or reclassifying.
Because of its medicinal value and the lack of an effective substitute,
marijuana should be reclassified as a Schedule II drug instead of a Schedule I drug, which
would allow it for certain medical uses. Other illegal drugs such as cocaine and heroin
are classified as Schedule II, even though they are considered habit forming and
dangerous, where marijuana, classified as a Schedule I, has never caused a death or
overdose and is not considered addictive. The federal government refuses to reclassify
marijuana because there is no proof that smoked marijuana is the most effective
available treatment for anything. (McCaffrey 27) There can be no proof until
marijuana has been tested in a series of clinical trials. There can be no clinical testing
of marijuana because the federal government will not allow them (Conant 26). Anyone who
has read the book Catch-22 will find this situation familiar.
The government opponents of medicinal marijuana are against it for
political rather than practical reasons. Clinton, who suffered in the polls after he
admitted to smoking pot, has taken a strong anti-drug stance to follow in the popular vein
of Reagan and Bushs war on drugs. Congress has taken a strong anti-drug
stance, which could be viewed as another example of Congress detachment from the
people they represent, since 35 states have laws that allow marijuana for medicinal use in
certain circumstances. The newly passed referendums in Arizona and California demonstrate
popular support of these laws, and that they couldnt be passed through
Californias legislature also demonstrates the representatives isolation from
the voters. Federal law, which bans marijuana for all uses, makes all these state laws
illegal. This issue represents the power struggle between the state governments and the
federal government. The federal government has no constitutional right to ban drugs,
especially not if it overrides a state law. This issue has become more than just marijuana
for treatment of the sick, it has grown to include the federal governments desire to
maintain its dominance over the state governments. Unfortunately, people whose morality
and patriotism prevent them from using marijuana to treat their cancer, AIDS, glaucoma, or
other illness pay the price.
The other opponents of marijuana as a form of medical treatment have
presented several illogical arguments against it. Many opponents argue that marijuana is a
gateway drug that often leads to harder drugs. This argument is easily
disproved by the fact that use of hard drugs in the Netherlands has decreased
significantly since marijuana was legalized (Medical Marijuana 23)u. Parents
are often worried that prescription marijuana will mean that more of it will get into the
hands of kids. Some of these parents have prescriptions for Morphine, Prozac, Zoloft,
Dexedrine, or countless other mood-altering drugs which they successfully keep out of
their childrens hands.
Marijuana should reclassified so its unique medicinal value can be
legally utilized to treat patients. How long would the loudest opponent of medicinal
marijuana live incapacitated by nausea or Marinol before he would turn to marijuana? Maybe
opponents should spend a month or two in chemotherapy before they deny patients the most
effective means of relief.
Works Cited
Brazaitis, Tom. The Illegal Wonder Drug. Plain Dealer 2
July. 1995: 1C-2C.
Journal backs medicinal use of marijuana. Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel 30 Jan.
1997: 3A.
Marijuana for the Sick. New York Times 30 Dec. 1996: A10.
Conant, Marcus. This Is Smart Medicine. Newsweek 3 Feb.
1997: 26.
McCaffrey, Barry. Were on a Perilous Path. Newsweek 3
Feb. 1997: 27.
Medical Marijuana. Issues and Controversies on File 10 Jan.
1997: 22-23.
|