| |
In recent years, more and more kids seem to be on a prescription drug
called Ritalin(methylphenidate). This drug is being handed out more and more by doctors as
a way of treating Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, a complex neurological
impairnment that prevents kids from concentrating. According to the Drug Enforcement
Agency, it rose fron 200 grams per 100,000 people to over 1400 grams per 100,000 people in
the last fifteen years. The National Institute of Mental Health estimates that about one
student in every classroom is believed to experience the disorder. The rate of Ritalin use
in the United States is at least five times higher than in the rest of the world according
to federal studies. Are doctors just catching this disabling affliction more often? Or
does society just want a convenient way to solve a complicated problem.
Ritalin is a central nervous system stimulant that is somewhat similar
to amphetamines. It was created in 1955, classified as a controlled substance in 1971, and
became the drug of choice for ADHD in 1981. It is also used in treating narcolepsy. It is
thought to activate the brain stem arousal system and cortex, and, like cocaine, works on
the neurotransmitter dopamine. It appears to increase the levels of dopamine in the
frontal lobe where attention and impulsive actions are regulated. When taken in its
intended form under a doctor's prescritption, it has moderate stimulant properties. There
has been a great deal of concern about it's addictive qualities and adverse affects.
ADHD is a relatively new disorder. It was introduced in 1980, where it
was labeled ADD(attention deficit disorder). In the 1950's, children were simply labeled
"hyperkinetic." The term "hyperactivity" was added in 1987, hence the
name ADHD. Not all children have the hyperactivity, and thus are labeled to have ADD. ADD
is not treated with Ritalin; antidepressants are more commonly used. One of the problems
with the label ADHD is that just because a child may be overly hyper, doesn't mean the
child is not paying attention. The problem is, the child is paying too much attention to
too many things at the same time.
ADHD is children's #1 childhood psychiatric disorder. The prevalence is
three times as likely in boys than girls. The children tend to be very bright, but are
poor students because they cna't settle down. They blurt questions out before they are
asked. They can't wait their turn, stop fidgeting their legs and tapping their pencils.
They tend to be forgetful, have problems following directions, and lose things easily, as
well as their tempers. This behavior occurs constantly. This may be a reason why teachers
and school psychologists are adament in their beliefs; these kids are disrupting their
classrooms, so they want the problem solved immeditately, and take the "quick
fix" approach. Experts believe that more than two million children (3-5%) have the
disorder.
Some scientists believe ADHD is a result of a problem in pregnancy
ranging from fetal alcohol syndrome to exposure to lead in utero. Others suggest that ADHD
is hereditary. Dr. Russel Barkley, of the University of Minnesota reports that nearly half
the ADHD children have a parent, and more than one third have a sibling, with the
disorder.
Ritalin as prescribed is taken orally, and takes effect in about 30
minutes and lasts for about 3-4 hours. Kids usually take 5-10 mg doses three times a day.
Although many experts report that Ritalin is a positive treatment in 9 out of 10 patienst,
and many parents and students claim the drug is a benefit in their lives', there are many
who question the drug's long-term effects, dangers, misdiagnosis, and non-medical abuse.
Diagnosis for ADHD isn't as easy as you think. There is no blood
test, no x-ray, or no cat scan to determine a biological cause for the disorder. Teachers,
even in preschool strongly advocate the drug(negative reinforcement???). School
psychologists are even prescribing the drug before giving an evaluation because there are
so many referrals and a lack of school psychologists (1:2100 students). Many times, it has
been shown, that psychiatrists who often diagnose for ADHD in children, are disdiagnosing
disorders similar to ADHD such as learning disabilities, depression or anxiety disorders;
disorders that do not neccessitate Ritalin as a therapy. Some doctors who are reluctant to
prescribe Ritalin find that the childeren's parents just switch doctors and find doctors
who will. Unfortunately, this is surprisingly easy. Doctors surveyed by the Archives of
Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine said they send ADHD children home in about an hour. The
children are not only sent home with just a prescription, but rarely any follow up care of
additional therapy is adnministered. Experts in the field of ADHD say behavior
modification techniques and extra help in school is a better way in treating the disorder.
Since it takes time to sit down and go through therapy sessions, and it takes time for
parents to fit tis all into their lifestyle, a pill is much more convenient. There are no
long term studies on the effects that it has on children, so many fear what complications
may occur later on in life.
Correct diagnosis would occur if doctors would take the time to provide
a complete examination of the patient. To make a correct ADHD diagnosis, it is important
to review the child's family history, give abstract cognitive tests, observe their
behavior, and run a slew of behavioral exams. Other disorders must be ruled out first.
Parents need to make sure a complete evaluation is carried out before putting a pill in a
child's mouth. One would think that every parent would explore every option before relying
on medication only.
Diagnosis would also be much easier if doctors could find a flaw in the
brain. Several studies have shown that ADHD brains look and function slightly different
that "normal" brains. PET(positron emission tomography) has shown that ADHD
brains use less glucose in the prefrontal lobe. The prefrontal lobe is the center for
impulse control and attention. By using less glucose-or energy, this would then agree with
the child's behavioral problems. Other tests show that there is less electrical activity
in the same region of the brain. Nonetheless, these studies have not yet been proven to be
the cause for the disorder.
Many people are concerned with the non-medical use of Ritalin, also.
Ritalin is a Schedule II controlled substance, which means it is a very powerful drug, and
in the same category as cocaine, methadone, and methamphetamines. The Manufacturer of
Ritalin, Ciba-Geiby Corporation, cautions doctors that many adverse side effects are
possible under normal dosage such as: nervousness, insomnia, decreased appetite, nausea,
vomiting, dizziness, heart palpitations, headaches, rise in heart rate and blood pressure,
skin rashes, itching, abdominal pain, weight loss, digestive problems, toxic psychosis,
psychotic episodes, and severe depression upon withdrawal. Many question if such a drug
should be so freely handed out to children because of it's possible dangerous effects.
Parents are even trying to lessen the restrictions on Ritalin so they won't have to make
monthly doctor visits.
It's rise on the black market has also been increasing. Since it is so
widely available, many kids sell the pills for 3-15 dollars a pill. The buyers then crush
up the pill and snort it, giving an intense high similar to cocaine. Some also dissolve it
in water and inject it intravenously. In these forms, it is highly addictive, and
withdrawal symptoms are also similar to cocaine. Some of the side effects at these high
doses may be life threatening: loss of appetite(may cause serious malnutrition), tremors
and muscle twitching, fevers, convulsions, and headaches(may be severe), irregular
heartbeat and respiration(may be profound and life threatening), anxiety, restlessness,
paranoia, hallucinations, delusions, excessive repetition of movements and meaningless
tasks, and formicaton(sensation of bugs or worms crawling under the skin). It seems to be
abused by high school kids and college students predominantly. Although the drug is too
complex to manufacture illegally, and it doesn't create the euphoric effect that cocaine
has, it seems to be an aid in studying for final exams. It allows students to stay up all
night allowing them to cram much easier.
It is important to remember that too many children in America are
suffering from this ailment, and yet too many kids are getting pills instead of proper
care. Although Ritalin currently seems to be an effective way in treating Attention
Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, we must not treat this disorder hastily. Our society must
realize that prescription drugs can have just as many complications as street drugs. Befor
writing out a prescription, or carelessly diagnosing ADHD, we must remember that these are
kids we are dealing with. They put all their faith in us to help them, and not just to
medicate them.
--------------------------------------------------------------
|